Two-Thirds of Britons Don't Trust Any Government With Their Chats
A poll for the Center for Democracy & Technology found 89 percent of British adults want a court order for access to their messages, and two-thirds wouldn't trust any government with encrypted chats.
TL;DR
- Of 2,000 British adults polled for the Center for Democracy & Technology, 89 percent said nobody should access their messages without a court order [^1].
- Two-thirds said they would not trust the current government, or any future one, with the power to access encrypted messages [^1].
Background
The UK government has long pushed for access to encrypted data, while the tech industry insists encryption works only if nobody holds a spare key [^1]. The dispute became public when Apple withdrew Advanced Data Protection from UK users after receiving a secret Technical Capability Notice under the Investigatory Powers Act [^1].
What happened
Public First conducted the survey for CDT in April, weighting results to reflect the population, with a margin of error of 2.2 percentage points, The Register reports [^1]. The distrust crossed party lines: among 2024 voters, 58 percent of Labour, 59 percent of Conservative, 56 percent of Liberal Democrat, 69 percent of Green and 75 percent of Reform voters said they would not trust any government with the power [^1].
93 percent said they have a right to private conversations online [^1]. 55 percent had not heard about the Apple notice [^1]. Only 12 percent supported the government being able to secretly order companies to provide access while barring them from revealing it; a third said it should not have that power at all, and 41 percent wanted more transparency or parliamentary oversight [^1]. 53 percent said the security risks of accessing encrypted messages outweighed the benefits, against 28 percent who saw more benefit [^1]. 84 percent worried that access mechanisms could create vulnerabilities for hackers and criminals, and 82 percent that the powers could be abused [^1].
Why it matters
Governments often frame encryption access as a public-safety measure people would support. This poll suggests the opposite in the UK: people across the political spectrum see a backdoor as a risk to themselves, not just to criminals. The secret-order model, the one used against Apple, is the least popular option of all [^1].
Practical example
Say a messaging app is ordered to build a way for authorities to read chats. The same opening that lets an agency in can be found and used by others, which is the risk 84 percent of respondents worried about [^1]. That is why encryption experts argue there is no backdoor that only the good guys can use.